As we adjourn from the core aspect of our Master's program, I have mixed feelings. On the positive side I have learned so much and feel so much more empowered regarding what I know, where EC research is going, and what we have yet to learn. On the less positive side, I am unhappy to be loosing those with whom I've worked so closely for so long... (sniff, sniff). I have made some significant life decisions of late, one of which was to accept a 6th grade teaching position at one of our local elementary schools. The situation was grim when I entered, so I have been over my head with the demands of the position. Coincidentally, this communication class has been so helpful and applicable to working with 12 year olds.
In order to handle it all, I think I will need to postpone my specialization until June, when the el school I work in adjourns for the summer. I may also see if I can change my specialization from administration, leadership and management to teaching adults. I have a lot to think about, so we will see.
Best of luck to you all. Thank you for all of your support, sharing your knowledge and experiences so that we all learn even more. Please stay in touch. If I can be of help in future collaborations please let me know.
With gratitude and kindest regards,
Dot Breeden
Sunday, December 23, 2012
Monday, December 10, 2012
The Adjournment of a Well Functioning Group
The first time I had ever heard of the stages of group development: "Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjouring" (Adapted from O'Hair and Wiemann, 2012, pp. 278) was from my daughter who participated in a month long NOLS course, the summer of 2010, at the age of 14 years. Although none of the group members knew one another prior to forming, by the end of the course they had successfully become a "high functioning group" (Adapted from O'Hair and Wiemann, 2012, pp. 278). When the time for adjournment came, the inter-relationships of the group were deep. Saying good bye to one another was not without a significant number of tears, and for Kira it included about 6 weeks of a deep sense of loss and grief... to the point where I was concerned about her health and well being. The group has remained close through Facebook. If grief, loss, and sadness are part of the adjournment process of a high-functioning group, that Kira's group was by definition a high functioning group.
Sunday, November 25, 2012
An Evaluation of My Personal Communication Style
In evaluating my communication style, I utilized the communication measures developed by Ruben, Palmgreen and Sypher (2009), which included the Communication Anxiety Inventory, the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale, and the Listening Styles Profile-16 (2009). The measures are presented as self-assessment questionnaires. When I completed the assessments I found, from the Communication Anxiety Inventory, that at times, my communication anxiety levels are "elevated", meaning that, "[I] feel uncomfortable in several communication contexts". This is true when I am trying to make conversation with people who are new to me. The self-assessment results from the Verbal Aggressiveness Scale rate my verbal aggressiveness as moderate: "[I] maintain a good balance between respect and consideration for others' viewpoints, and the ability to argue fairly by attacking the facts of a position rather than the person holding that position." From the third self-assessment, Listening Styles Profile, I find that I am in "Group 1": "[I] am empathetic and concerned with the emotions of others. This listening style helps [me] to build relationships, but it can interfere with proper judgment because [I] tend to be very trusting of others".
After completing the assessments myself, I invited my daughter, Kira, (pictured at left) and my dear friend and colleague Berit (pictured below) to evaluate my communication style using the same assessments. I was pleased to see that they both evaluated me as "moderate" in verbal aggressiveness and as "Group 1" on the Listening Styles Profile, which were congruent with my own findings. The results differed however in the Communication Anxiety Inventory. Kira rated me as having "mild" communication anxiety meaning, "[I] feel a bit uneasy in some communication situations and somewhat more confident in other contexts. Communication does not seem to be something that []I worry a great deal about" (2009). Berit rated my communication anxiety as "low" meaning, "[I] feel comfortable communicating in most situations and feel confident in anticipating such encounters" (2009). I am not surprised by this aspect of the evaluation, because although I feel anxious at times in communication situations, I also endeavor to calm any feelings of anxiety as quickly as possible for the sake of effective communication, therefore others are less likely to sense anxiety on my part.
Resources:
Rubin, R. B., Rubin, M. A., & Sypher, H.E. (Eds) (2009). Communication research measures: A resource book. New York: Routledge.
Rubin, R.D., Rubin, M. A., Grahm, E. E., Perse, E. M., & Seibold, D. R. (Eds) (2009). Communication research measures II: A sourcebook. New York: Routledge
Sunday, November 18, 2012
Resisting Cultural Myopia
I recognize in myself, a tendency to take great care in how I communicate with the Hispanic families of this area. I am careful to utilize words and phrases that do not seem assumptive or superior in any way. Large extended families are typical in this area of New Mexico and of the greatest importance- well beyond the pursuit of high-powered careers and the pursuit of wealth. One way of showing respect in this culture is to ask about the children. No conversation is complete without inquiring, by name, after the children of the family, as well as asking after the health and well-being of the family elders. At St. Michael's High School many of the students are athletes and are well supported by their families in their athletic endeavors. Naturally it is important to comment upon the accomplishments of these athletes... in order to show a genuine interest. Even though, in our family, sports come second to academics, that is not necessarily the case for all of the families at St. Michael's. As a non-Hispanic White, another way of showing respect to this population, which has historically been shown very little respect is to ask, "What do you think? What do you suggest we do in this situation? Can you help me with this problem?" Because the intergenerational ties in this community are so strong, relevant information and wisdom about the area is passed down from one generation to the next. It is a mistake to cast off this information as irrelevant. The families I know, work hard to give their children a private education. They are devout in their ways regarding the Catholic church, and they care immensely about the well being of their children. However, many of these same families have been consistently shunned, and shown very little respect over the decades by non-Hispanic new comers to the area, and I often am aware of an overall sense of caution and sometimes suspicion between the cultures of the area. Although the situation has improved, in many ways the racial relations in Northern New Mexico still have a lot of room for improvement... and each culture here: Northern New Mexico Hispanic, Native American, Mexican immigrant and non-Hispanic White, has an equal responsibility to reduce and eliminate cultural myopia.
Sunday, November 11, 2012
Isolating Non-verbal Communication from the Corresponding Verbal Communication: What Can We Learn?
This was an interesting exercise... Choose a T.V. show of which you are unfamiliar. Watch the show with the audio omitted, gleaning as much information as possible through the visual observation of the non-verbal messages displayed by the actors. Because we choose not to have television in our home, most TV shows produced since 2000 or so I am fairly unfamiliar with. So I browsed Netflix and chose two different shows: Parks and Recreation, Season 1 Pilot Episode, and Bones "The Mastodon in the Room" Season 6 Episode 1.In Parks and Recreation the non-verbal clues were fairly obvious. As I watched without sound, I was able to glean, through written clues, that Leslie Knope works in the Parks and Recreation Department of Indiana. Through her interactions with others in meetings it became clear that she works with a group of people. It also was apparent through her facial expressions that she is romantically attracted to character Mark Brendanawicz. Character Ann Perkins, at a public meeting, appears through her facial expressions and body language to be a concerned citizen, and Leslie seems to show an interest in addressing Ann's concerns positively. Character Tom Haverford points to his wedding ring during the public meeting, which to me meant he was indicating that he is married. However, the fact that he was actually "coming on" to the Ann Perkins character was not evident to me until I watched the show again with the sound on.
In Bones the non-verbal clues, I thought, were less obvious than in Parks and Recreation. However, even without sound, I was able to understand that Dr. Brennan lacks and longs for social connectedness with others. The scene shows Dr. Brennan at the airport, on separate occasions saying goodbye to people she clearly knows and feels warmly about.... in particular the character Special Agent Seeley Booth. This is made apparent by the slow motion image of them reluctantly letting go of each other's hands when they say good bye. Through deliberate and purposeful body language, the scene in Indonesia shows Dr. Brennan as competent, determined and brave, while her colleague, the character Daisy, through her lack of deliberate body language and the constant look of confusion on her face, and Dr. Brennan's look of bafflement as she observes Daisy in her underwear, seems to communicate her subservient role to Dr. Brennan. All of these "assumptions" on my part were confirmed when verbal language was included.
In this exercise however we were not only eliminating the verbal language from the communication, but the music as well. Music plays a tremendous role in our understanding of what is happening in a movie or television show. I think that more research related to the role of music in communication is warranted. The findings, I believe, would be relevant to this topic and interesting. Another thought I had while conducting this exercise, is just how good the actors are at assuming the personalities of the characters they play. This seems even more obvious when observing all the non-verbal communication that the actors "act" while delivering their verbal lines. I really found the acting competence to be remarkable.
Saturday, November 3, 2012
How Does She Do It?
![]() |
| Michelle Obama, 2012 Democratic National Convention. |
When I started thinking about people whom I know are good communicators, my first thought was- Not Me! The exception, I suppose, would be when I communicate with my girls, and when I communicate in the classroom with my students. The next person, that came to mind, as someone I really do recognize as a good communicator, was my U.S. History Professor at Indiana University. The hall in which he taught could seat 400 students. Often times, however, there was standing room only in the hall, because other students not enrolled in the class would sit/stand in on his lectures. The third person I thought of is the president of the high school at which my daughters attend school. I have complimented, President Marcia Sullivan before on her speeches- even those impromptu speeches she often finds herself giving to parents, alumni, faculty, community members, or students. Then I asked my 16 year old daughter what she thought about the topic- Who do we know, or know of, that seems to have good communication skills? Without hesitation, she suggested I take a look at the speech given by Michelle Obama at the 2012 National Democratic Convention. Like many people, apparently, who watched this speech, I was moved at times to tears or near tears. Why is that? Sure the content of the speech was meaningful, but there had to be something in the delivery as well. After all, a well written speech that is poorly given immediately becomes an example of poor communication. So... in regard to the people mentioned above: my history professor, Marcia Sullivan- President of St. Michael's High School, and Michelle Obama- First Lady of the United States; what is it about the way in which these people communicate that makes them good communicators? What is the common factor? Well... I think it is that they are all easy to listen to. In the case of Michelle Obama, her words are spoken at a natural and conversational pace. Her body language and eye contact correspond well with what she is saying. The inflections in her voice rise and fall in very natural way. She uses silence at all the right moments, to contrast important points she is making. The sincerity in her voice, even the slight quavering when she spoke of her daughters, made it seem like she truly was passionate about what she was saying... believable.
I would love to be able to articulate my thoughts and ideas as well as Michelle Obama did in her speech- where there is no loss for words, the message is unmistakably clear and delivered in a natural, believable, and easy to listen to way. Hmm... I think I need a lot of practice.
Resources:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTPdKUA9Ipg
Saturday, October 27, 2012
Hopes and Goals...
![]() |
| Roll over for description. |
Hello to All the Children of the World
From the album, Wee Sing Around the World, Lyrics & Music by Nancy Klein and Pam Beall
Hello, Bonjour, Buenos di’as,
G’day, Guten Tag, Konnichi wa
Ciao, Shalom, Dobrey dyen,
Hello to all the children of the world!
Verse
We live in diff’rent places from all around the world.
We speak in many diff’rent ways.___
Though some things might be diff’rent, we’re children just the same,
And we all like to sing and play.
Hello, Bonjour, Buenos di’as,
G’day, Guten Tag, Konnichi wa
Ciao, Shalom, Dobrey dyen,
Hello to all the children of the world!
Verse
There are children in the deserts,
and children in the towns
And children who live by the sea.
If we could meet each other to run and sing and play,
Then what good friends we all could be.
Refrain
Hello, Bonjour, Buenos di’as,
G’day, Guten Tag, Konnichi wa
Ciao, Shalom, Dobrey dyen,
Hello to all the children of the world!
I challenge the EC community to go way beyond bilingualism, and truly embrace teaching practices that guarantee an environment conducive to equity and social justice for each individual within the environment. A student is more than, for example, "a child from Mexico". She is a person, who within her own culture also has her own name, her own family, her own experiences, her own thoughts and ideas... just like any other child. It is a matter of going beyond surface culture, which unfortunately is often the status quo of cultural education, and pursue a deep understanding of the child and their family.
Many, many thanks to everyone for all the thoughts, ideas, and shared experiences that have made the content of this class that much more tangible.
Sunday, October 21, 2012
In Preparation for a Romanian Family
In preparing for a family from Romania, I would endeavor to know more
about Romania, specifically about families and children in Romania. The internet is a great resource of
information about other cultures.
For example on the following site, http://www.kwintessential.co.uk/resources/global-etiquette/romania.html,
I can learn that Romania is part of Eastern Europe, and that the capital of
Romania is Bucharest. The ethnic
make-up of Romania is fairly homogenous by comparison to the U.S. with nearly
90% of the people being of Romanian decent. The religions of Romania are Christian-based, with most
people being Eastern Orthodox.
Romanian families tend to be patriarchal, and it is expected that one
will show respect to elders by addressing them with their appropriate title and
surname, rather than their first name.
Romanians respect humility in themselves and others. As a Montessori teacher, I would also
utilize the Internet to make contact with Montessori teachers in Romania, for
instance Montessori Kindergarten of Bucharest, http://www.gradinitamontessori.ro/en/.
As a Montessori teacher, it is common to come in contact with families from all over
the world. In preparation for
receiving a Romanian family to my classroom I would contact the family I
know whose daughter was enrolled in the Montessori preschool program of my
school. I would ask them for
translation services if necessary, and for advise on how to serve the cultural
needs of the family. I would also
introduce the families to one another.
Romanians traditionally take Christmas and Easter rather seriously, with
elaborate customs and celebrations.
I would plan to invite the family to share with the class their
traditional ways of celebrating important holidays in Romania, such as the art
of painting Easter Eggs.
Through my own personal research of Romania via the Internet, Romanian
Montessori Teachers, and local Romanian families with whom I am associated, I
would basically hope to gain enough information about Romania to have an
intelligent and respectful conversation with the family upon their arrival at
the school. This is the first, and
most critical step in creating a trans-cultural rapport. Once communications and trust are
established, the family school relationships can grow beyond what is U.S. and
what is Romanian, to something more personal such as the characteristics of
this family specifically.
![]() |
| Spring time in Romania |
Thursday, October 18, 2012
Extra: The "Peaceable Kingdom"/The Early Childhood Environment
I once explained the notion of creating the early childhood environment as a "safe haven" for all who enter, to a colleague of mine. I described the early learning environment that I endeavor to create as a Peaceable Kingdom (“Worcester Art Museum, 1833), from the well-known painting, which I saw as a
child. I am not a religious person at all, but I can connect with
the verse in Isaiah (11:6) that states, "In that day the wolf and the lamb
will live together; the leopard will lie down with the baby goat. The calf and
the yearling will be safe with the lion, and a little child will lead them
all" (Isaiah, Holy Bible, New Living Translation, 2004). My colleague questioned the fruitfulness of my endeavors, and
asked if I really thought that the peaceful environment we created in the
classroom could possibly transcend into the child’s life away from school. I told her that my goal was to give
every child in the class a chance to experience a peaceful environment… to see
what it looks like, to hear what it sounds like, to feel what it feels like
to be safe- functioning fully in the same space as people who are not just like
them, and to experience the countless benefits of that peaceful environment and know what it takes to make that happen.
My hope is that these children will understand, as well as develop and
have the skills to create peaceful, productive environments of their own as
they mature into adulthood.
Resources:
Isaiah, Holy Bible, New Living
Translation. (2004, 2011). Isaiah 11:6. Biblos. Retrieved October 18,
2012, from http://bible.cc/isaiah/11-6.htm
Worcester
Art Museum - Edward Hicks: The Peaceable Kingdom. (n.d.).Worcester Art
Museum. Retrieved October 18, 2012, from
http://www.worcesterart.org/Collection/American/1934.65.html
Sunday, October 14, 2012
The Personal Side of Bias, Prejudice, and Oppression
I'm going to retell just one of what ended up being many gender transgressions against a friend of mine when she was a firefighter in the Santa Fe Fire Department. My friend Stacia (I've changed her name) decided to become a paramedic, which in Santa Fe also means you become a fire fighter. The decision to join the department came when as a waitress, she became aware that upon leaving the establishment, one of the female customers had been beaten and raped. The victimized woman came back to the establishment seeking help, and the fire department (paramedics) were called. My friend Stacia, comforted the woman until the paramedics arrived, at which point she made room for the paramedics to care for the woman. As Stacia stood back and watched, she saw the fear in the woman's face as she was confronted by the male paramedics, who, with great emotional detachment, followed the protocols they had been taught in regard to efficiently assessing the condition of a rape victim. Stacia said she thought to herself, "I can do that better." So Stacia went through the classes and the training and became a fire fighter/paramedic. She was one of the first women admitted to the department, which traditionally had been dominated by Hispanic men, but eventually admitting a few white men as well. Over the course of many years, Stacia finally worked her way up to Captain of Station 1 (The busiest fire station in the city, and responsible for the greatest amount of historically significant and valuable real estate). But as a woman, in the Santa Fe Fire Department life was difficult for Stacia. Stacia married another fire fighter and when she became pregnant with her first child, she was surprised by the blatant lack of support she received from the department. Many of the men in the department felt that women did not belong among their ranks, and especially pregnant women. After her baby arrived she wanted to make sure that her daughter received breast milk for at least the first year of her life. In order to make this happen Stacia pumped her breasts when she was away from her daughter, and stored the breast milk in the freezer at work. One day when she went to retrieve the bottles of milk she had stored, before going home, she found that the freezer had been chained, and pad-locked shut, by her crew. Although angry and more than eager to get home to her daughter, she remained focused. As the well trained and resourceful woman she was, she went down to the fire engine, retrieved a pair of bolt cutters, went back to the freezer and cut the chain off of the freezer. She retrieved the breast milk she had stored (thankful that it was still there) and went home. No complaints filed. Later Stacia had a second child. Over the course of many years, Stacia was finally honored with the rank of Captain, and with great care and fortitude was able to develop and lead a closely knit, respectful group of men, all the way up to the time of her retirement.
When I first heard this story, I found it first of all hard to believe... then I found it hard to really feel what Stacia must have felt. I remember as a mother how hard it was for me to leave my children when I was nursing... but to come off of a 48 hour shift just to find that all the breast milk I had so carefully stored was locked in the freezer by one of my crew mates would have been appalling. And no one... Not one member of her crew was willing to help her retrieve the milk. It has been 10 years since Stacia shared that story with me. Now that I am ten years older I look back on the incident and am even more appalled. That fact that Stacia did not file any complaints was probably, at the time, the wisest thing to do.
Sometimes the best thing we can do, when we have little to no recourse, in our attempts to fight back against bias, prejudice, and oppression, is to make sure that we teach our sons and daughters to not engage in nor tolerate discrimination.
When I first heard this story, I found it first of all hard to believe... then I found it hard to really feel what Stacia must have felt. I remember as a mother how hard it was for me to leave my children when I was nursing... but to come off of a 48 hour shift just to find that all the breast milk I had so carefully stored was locked in the freezer by one of my crew mates would have been appalling. And no one... Not one member of her crew was willing to help her retrieve the milk. It has been 10 years since Stacia shared that story with me. Now that I am ten years older I look back on the incident and am even more appalled. That fact that Stacia did not file any complaints was probably, at the time, the wisest thing to do.
Sometimes the best thing we can do, when we have little to no recourse, in our attempts to fight back against bias, prejudice, and oppression, is to make sure that we teach our sons and daughters to not engage in nor tolerate discrimination.
Monday, October 1, 2012
The Teaching of Racism
I remember a scenario involving a micro-aggression
witnessed by my girls while visiting their grandmother in South Carolina.
My girls aged 16 years and 13 years were visiting their grandmother and
her husband last summer near Charleston, South Carolina. While having
dinner with extended family members of the family, one of the men at the table
brought something up about Jewish people. He then turned to his son, who
was about 8 years old and said, "Do you have any Jews in your class?"
His son replied by saying he didn't know. Then his father said to
his son, "Always try to sit next to the Jewish kid in the class so you can
get good grades." When my girls came home and reported this incident
to me I was appalled but not surprised. They [my girls] were both shocked
at the time. This was indeed a father's careful instruction to his son on
how to perceive Jewish children, and how to behave with micro-aggressions
against them.
A quote from this weeks introduction page
comes from one of my favorite musicals South Pacific, "You've got
to be taught to hate and fear; you've got to be taught from year to year; it's
got to be drummed in your dear little ear; you've got to be carefully
taught." I was about 8 years old when I first became acquainted with
this musical, and I remember discussing the lyrics of this song with my mother
who was passionate about anti-racism.
Another important musical to see, which explores anti-semitism in Russia is Fiddler on the Roof, shown above.
Sunday, September 23, 2012
Culture and Diversity: 3 Perspectives
I spoke with 3 friends, and asked them to share their definitions of culture and of diversity. One friend, Topi, grew up in Finland, another friend, Monika, grew up in what was formerly East Germany, and my third friend, Tracey, grew up here in the U.S. All three currently live in the U.S.
I asked each person to define culture. Topi defined culture as the environment in which one lives. Culture includes the physical environment (In Topi's case, Finland, which has a significant affect on the culture of the people), how people adapt to that environment, and how that influences the way people think about what they perceive. Monika agreed with this definition and added that culture changes over time given influences for example from other cultures. Monika remembers well when the former Soviet Union controlled much of what went on in East Germany. She also remembers well, when in 1989 the Berlin Wall came down and reunification was enacted. Monika stressed that a single geographical place can undergo drastic cultural changes over a given period f time. Tracey, defined culture as the social aspects of a society.
I also asked each person to define diversity. Topi defined diversity as basically what we have in the U.S. He said that diversity makes life "interesting". Topi also said that in Finland there is very little diversity, although it is changing. Many Finns he said, are rather "closed-minded" in their willingness to appreciate other cultures, within their own country. Like Topi, Monika stated that social diversity is what exists in the U.S. By comparison she said that Germany is not diverse. Monika shared a conversation she had with her father recently when she went back to Germany to visit. They were talking about the non-German ethnic groups that were entering Germany. Monika's father stated that if people from other countries want to come to Germany, than it is up to them to assimilate to German culture- that they have chosen to give up their own cultures in coming to Germany. Monika then said, that as a German living in the U.S., she would greatly resent being asked to give up her German culture in order to live in the U.S. She stressed that she and her husband Topi are in the U.S. in part because of the openness and social diversification of the country. Tracey defined social diversification as the integration of cultures.
We have learned that social diversification is a strength. Both Topi and Monika reflect this point of view as Monika stresses that one of the major reasons they came to the U.S. was for the cultural diversification.
The people I spoke with about the topics of culture and diversification are parents of children I have had in my class. It is typical for teachers and families in Montessori school to form strong friendships as the children remain in the same class for 3 years. Therefore connections often last well beyond the time that their children move on from preschool. The discussions we have had regarding culture and diversity have, to a point, confirmed and reinforced the lessons I learned about diversity and culture when I taught in South Central Los Angeles. Immigrants to the U.S. need to be considered one family at a time. People have different reasons for immigrating to the U.S. and it is critical that as Early childhood professions we understand as much as possible the unique reasons for the families move to the U.S., because the reasons for immigration provide meaning for the needs/desires/wishes families have for themselves and their children once in the U.S.
I asked each person to define culture. Topi defined culture as the environment in which one lives. Culture includes the physical environment (In Topi's case, Finland, which has a significant affect on the culture of the people), how people adapt to that environment, and how that influences the way people think about what they perceive. Monika agreed with this definition and added that culture changes over time given influences for example from other cultures. Monika remembers well when the former Soviet Union controlled much of what went on in East Germany. She also remembers well, when in 1989 the Berlin Wall came down and reunification was enacted. Monika stressed that a single geographical place can undergo drastic cultural changes over a given period f time. Tracey, defined culture as the social aspects of a society.
I also asked each person to define diversity. Topi defined diversity as basically what we have in the U.S. He said that diversity makes life "interesting". Topi also said that in Finland there is very little diversity, although it is changing. Many Finns he said, are rather "closed-minded" in their willingness to appreciate other cultures, within their own country. Like Topi, Monika stated that social diversity is what exists in the U.S. By comparison she said that Germany is not diverse. Monika shared a conversation she had with her father recently when she went back to Germany to visit. They were talking about the non-German ethnic groups that were entering Germany. Monika's father stated that if people from other countries want to come to Germany, than it is up to them to assimilate to German culture- that they have chosen to give up their own cultures in coming to Germany. Monika then said, that as a German living in the U.S., she would greatly resent being asked to give up her German culture in order to live in the U.S. She stressed that she and her husband Topi are in the U.S. in part because of the openness and social diversification of the country. Tracey defined social diversification as the integration of cultures.
We have learned that social diversification is a strength. Both Topi and Monika reflect this point of view as Monika stresses that one of the major reasons they came to the U.S. was for the cultural diversification.
The people I spoke with about the topics of culture and diversification are parents of children I have had in my class. It is typical for teachers and families in Montessori school to form strong friendships as the children remain in the same class for 3 years. Therefore connections often last well beyond the time that their children move on from preschool. The discussions we have had regarding culture and diversity have, to a point, confirmed and reinforced the lessons I learned about diversity and culture when I taught in South Central Los Angeles. Immigrants to the U.S. need to be considered one family at a time. People have different reasons for immigrating to the U.S. and it is critical that as Early childhood professions we understand as much as possible the unique reasons for the families move to the U.S., because the reasons for immigration provide meaning for the needs/desires/wishes families have for themselves and their children once in the U.S.
Friday, September 14, 2012
Cultural Items of Personal Significance? A Hypothetical Scenario.
Our assignment for this week presents a “what if”
scenario: “Consider that a major
catastrophe has almost completely devastated the infrastructure of your
country. The emergency government
has decided that the surviving citizens will be best served if they are
evacuated to other countries willing to take refugees. You and your immediate family are among
the survivors of this catastrophic event… You are told that you are told that
your host country’s culture is completely different from your own, and that you
might have to stay there permanently… you can only take 3 small items with you…
You decide to take three items… that represent your family culture” (Walden University, 2012).
After being assured that the needs of basic survival will be
met, I would simply take photos of my children. Although there are many objects and symbols that represent
my personal identity and family culture, I would not feel it practical to take
them given this precarious scenario.
Therefore, I would simply take the photos of my children. The rest of my personal identity and
family culture is within myself.
Any symbolic recreation of that I feel confident I could create anew in
my family’s new location. If I
could only bring in one item, I would choose a photo that represented my girls
and myself together. The decision
to bring only a photo of my family is reflective of who I am as a person and
what I think is important… that being my family, which in this scenario will be
with me. In the case of such a
catastrophic event my practical and pragmatic side would surface, guiding my
decisions in such a way as to ensure the safety and wellbeing of my
children. Adapting to the new
culture would become the priority, reinventing the culture I left behind would
be secondary and come after some amount of stability had been achieved in the
new environment.
Nadiyah Taylor, faculty member of the Early Childhood
Development Faculty at Las Positas College in Livermore, CA, (Laureate Education Inc., 2011) suggests that everything an
individual does is related to culture- what we say, what we think, what we
value, what we eat and how we eat, what we wear and how we wear it, even how we
sleep and go to the bathroom are all defined by culture. For the purpose of this discussion an
individual’s culture is defined by the individual’s environment as well as the relationships
and experiences the individual encounters within that environment. One possible way of defining an
individual’s culture is through the symbols and objects the individual chooses
to represent the important aspects of their personal identity. What symbols or objects does one choose
to represent the most important aspects of one’s own culture?
Our assignment for this week presents a “what if”
scenario: “Consider that a major
catastrophe has almost completely devastated the infrastructure of your
country. The emergency government
has decided that the surviving citizens will be best served if they are
evacuated to other countries willing to take refugees. You and your immediate family are among
the survivors of this catastrophic event… You are told that you are told that
your host country’s culture is completely different from your own, and that you
might have to stay there permanently… you can only take 3 small items with you…
You decide to take three items… that represent your family culture” (Walden University, 2012).
After being assured that the needs of basic survival will be
met, I would simply take photos of my children. Although there are many objects and symbols that represent
my personal identity and family culture, I would not feel it practical to take
them given this precarious scenario.
Therefore, I would simply take the photos of my children. The rest of my personal identity and
family culture is within myself.
Any symbolic recreation of that I feel confident I could create anew in
my family’s new location. If I
could only bring in one item, I would choose a photo that represented my girls
and myself together. The decision
to bring only a photo of my family is reflective of who I am as a person and
what I think is important… that being my family, which in this scenario will be
with me. In the case of such a
catastrophic event my practical and pragmatic side would surface, guiding my
decisions in such a way as to ensure the safety and wellbeing of my
children. Adapting to the new
culture would become the priority, reinventing the culture I left behind would
be secondary and come after some amount of stability had been achieved in the
new environment.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)














